Page 42 - When surgery alone won’t cut it - Valerie Maureen Monpellier
P. 42

Chapter 2
 Table 4:
Meta-analysis on effect of depressive symptoms on weight loss in RYGB patients
Author, yr.
Hatoum, 2008 Silver, 2006 Kruseman, 2010 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Alger-Mayer, 2009 Sallet, 2007 Sallet, 2007 Sallet, 2007 Sallet, 2007 Gorin, 2009
Love, 2008 Love, 2008 Beck, 2012 Yanos, 2014 Fox, 2016 Wise, 2015 Wise, 2015 Brandao, 2015 pooled ES
95%CI
1.57, 4.85 -2.48, 0.82 -7.22,-3.98 -0.96, 2.30 1.95, 5.21 2.08, 5.34 4.37, 7.65 14.33, 17.59 12.77, 16.03 7.65, 10.89 4.74, 8.02 -1.66, 1.56 1.10, 4.32 -1.32, 1.90 -4.31, -1.09 -3.74, -0.46 0.30, 3.56 -2.18, 1.08 -2.43, 0.73 -10.48, -7.40 -2.67, 0.47 -0.28, 2.04 0.89, 3.79 -14.99, -11.67 -1.01, 3.95
    FU
   Depressive symptoms
 No depressive symptoms
   ES
    BMI
 EWL
   N
  BMI
 EWL
   N
   12M
   51.38
  67.20
    111
   52.52
  63.99
    140
   3.21
   24.2M
 47.43
82.82
  69
 49.97
83.65
  71
 -0.83
   8y
  46.73
 65.90
   80
  45.46
 71.50
   48
  -5.60
   3M
   50.50
  47.91
    64
   51.14
  47.24
    93
   0.67
   6M
 50.50
64.02
  64
 51.14
60.44
  93
 3.58
   12M
   50.50
  73.83
    64
   51.14
  70.12
    93
   3.71
   24M
  50.50
 71.84
   41
  51.14
 65.83
   54
  6.01
   36M
 50.50
75.43
  25
 51.14
59.47
  36
 15.96
   48M
   50.50
  71.06
    16
   51.14
  56.66
    23
   14.40
   60M
 50.50
67.39
  9
 51.14
58.12
  14
 9.27
   72M
   50.50
  66.11
    9
   51.14
  59.73
    11
   6.38
   6M
  45.03
 57.19
   70
  44.95
 57.24
   119
  -0.05
   12M
 45.03
73.51
  65
 44.95
70.80
  117
 2.71
   24M
   45.03
  78.83
    42
   44.95
  78.54
    73
   0.29
   36M
 45.03
66.63
  8
 44.95
69.33
  14
 -2.70
   6M
   46.50
  56.80
    47
   47.40
  58.90
    57
   -2.10
   6M
  46.40
 51.16
   48
  48.42
 49.23
   68
  1.93
   12M
 46.40
74.88
  48
 48.42
75.43
  68
 -0.55
   23.2M
   47.46
  77.57
    14
   45.54
  78.42
    29
   -0.85
   8.6y
 55.39
73.41
  27
 52.47
82.35
  70
 -8.94
   12M
  45.44
 63.33
   67
  44.77
 64.43
   30
  -1.10
   6M
   49.14
  53.66
    56
   48.41
  52.78
    591
   0.88
   12M
 49.14
71.31
  56
 48.41
68.97
  591
 2.34
   28.6M
   44.79
  53.96
    18
   45.34
  67.28
    80
   -13.33
     48.35
 66.91
   1118
  48.59
 65.44
   2583
  1.47
                                                      yr. = year of publication; FU: follow-up in months (M) or years (Y); BMI: Body Mass Index; EWL: percentage excess weight loss; N = number of patients; ES: effect size; CI: confidence interval
42
   40   41   42   43   44