Page 34 - When surgery alone won’t cut it - Valerie Maureen Monpellier

Chapter 2
34
Table 1:
Overview of included studies and results
Author, yr.
Design FU
N BMI
Moderator(s) & definition
Effect
Compher, 2012 el Chaar, 2011 Song, 2008 Gould, 2007 Shen, 2004
cross. 6 - 24M pros. 12M retro. 6,12 M retro. 12, 36M pros. 12M
60 52.0 177 n.a. 78 n.a. 85 n.a. 115 47.7
Compliant: returned at FU 12 months postop
positive
Hatoum, 2008
pros. 12M
246 48.0
Compliant: attended >= 90% of appointments
Physical activity: ability to clime 2 flight of stairs / walk 2 city block Depression: present or absent during preop evaluation
positive positive
no difference
Harper, 2007 Robinson, 2014 Hildebrandt, 1998
pros. 12M cross. 5.8 Y cross. n.a.
105 48.0 274 53.3 102 n.a.
Compliant: returned for annual appointment
positive
Livhits, 2010
retro. 40.1M
148 46.2 110 49.5
Compliant: ≥1 attendance of postoperative support groups Physical activity: International Physical Activity Questionnaire-short Depression: assessed with no specification
Binge eating: Bing Eating Scale
positive positive
no difference negative
Coleman, 2010
retro. ≥12M
Compliance : number of missed postoperative appointments Physical activity: Million Behavioural Medicine Diagnostics Depression: Beck Depression Inventory
Binge eating: according to DSM-IV criteria
no difference positive negative negative
Forbush, 2011 Bond, 2009 Welch, 2008 Silver, 2006
cross. max 5 Y pros. 12 M cross. 14.5 M cross. 24.2 M
162 n.a. 190 49.8 200 53.5 140 49.8
Physical activity: Arizona Activity Frequency Questionnaire
Physical activity: Physical Activity Questionnaire short form
Physical activity: Bariatric Surgery Self-management Questionnaire Physical activity: part of Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System
positive positive positive positive
Compliant: missed <25% of preoperative appointments
no difference
Compliant: >5 support group meeting
positive
Compliant: attended every appointment
positive
Compliant: >3 FU moments after surgery
no difference
Compliance: regular attendance support groups Physical activity: y/n; times/week and minutes
positive positive
Compliant: patient who said they did attend support group
no difference